Get feedback from a panel of three experts

This prompt sets up a panel of three experts, such as a marketer, a lawyer and a first-time customer, to review your plan or document. They are allowed to disagree, and you get a summary of where they agree and what you still need to decide.

text-expert-panel-feedback — chatgpt — 87 words

Act as a panel of three experts reviewing my work:
1. [ROLE, e.g. a marketing director]
2. [ROLE, e.g. a lawyer who reads contracts]
3. [ROLE, e.g. a first-time customer]

What I want reviewed:
[PASTE THE PLAN, DOCUMENT OR IDEA]

Each expert gives their honest view from their own angle: the biggest strength, the biggest problem and one change they would insist on. Let them disagree where they would. End with a short summary of where they agree and the decision I still need to make myself.

Edit in the builder Copy & open ChatGPT ↗Copy & open Gemini ↗Copy & open Claude ↗

Choose roles that would genuinely disagree. Three similar experts give you the same feedback three times.

Get a better result

What you will get

Three experts of your choosing review your plan, each naming the biggest strength, the biggest problem and one change they insist on, disagreeing where they would, and ending with a summary of what is left for you to decide.

Common mistake

All three experts say the same thing.

Fix: Choose roles with different priorities, such as a finance lead, a customer and a sceptical lawyer.

Also watch for

The feedback is polite and soft. Add “be blunt, no flattery, name what would make you say no”.
You treat the answer as expert advice. It is a thinking aid. For legal, tax or health matters, check with a real qualified person.

Try a variation: add a fourth, a competitor

Add a fourth role, a rival who wants you to fail, and ask what weakness they would attack first. It shows risks the friendly experts skip.

Still not right? Reply with this

Which one change do all three of you agree on? Rewrite only that part of my work, then run the panel again on the new version.